
Hollander Boutique Hotel
Best for downtown arts, nightlife, and a social pool/bar scene within walking distance of museums and theaters.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hollander Boutique Hotel is a 1933 Art Deco boutique hotel in downtown St. Petersburg that suits travelers who want walkable access to museums, theaters, bars, and a social pool scene. Waterline Villas & Marina, Autograph Collection is an upscale marina resort on Anna Maria Island built around villa-style rooms and a dockside setting — read this if you want a quieter waterfront stay with kitchens and marina access.
Updated

Best for downtown arts, nightlife, and a social pool/bar scene within walking distance of museums and theaters.

Best for families or couples who want upscale villa-style accommodations with kitchens and direct marina/water access on Anna Maria Island.
When Hollander Boutique Hotel wins: choose Hollander if you want to be in the middle of downtown St. Petersburg — walking distance to the Palladium, Dali Museum area, restaurants, and live-music venues — plus a lively on-site bar, pool parties, and an independently run spa next door.
When Waterline Villas & Marina, Autograph Collection wins: choose Waterline when you prefer an island-marina setting, self-contained villas with kitchens and living space, easy access to boating/kayaking, and a quieter waterfront rhythm away from city crowds.
Bottom line: Hollander is the place for an active downtown trip with social dining and nightlife; Waterline is the better pick for an upscale, marina-centered Anna Maria Island stay where waterfront access and villa-style rooms matter more than proximity to city attractions.
| Category | Hollander Boutique Hotel | Waterline Villas & Marina, Autograph Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, downtown boutique with an active social scene | Upscale marina resort with villa accommodations and a quieter waterfront feel |
| Location | Downtown St. Petersburg; walking distance to theaters, museums, and waterfront parks | Holmes Beach on Anna Maria Island; on the waterfront with a dock and walkways to water |
| Size (rooms) | About 96 rooms (historic boutique scale) | 37 individually furnished guestrooms/villas |
| Room type highlights | Mix of Standard Rooms and Suites in an Art Deco building | Grand Villa, 2 Bedrooms (Island); Villa, 2 Bedrooms (Balcony); other 2-bedroom villa variants with kitchens |
| Pools & outdoor space | Outdoor heated saltwater pool with cabanas and poolside HH20 bar; hosts pool events | Outdoor pool, pool sun loungers, firepit, terrace and marina/dock areas |
| Restaurants & bars | The Tap Room Bar & Grill (restaurant + bar), HH20 pool bar, Common Grounds coffee shop | The Chateau Anna Maria (American restaurant with bar/lounge) and limited room service |
| Spa & wellness | Harmony Eco Spa (independently owned, on the hotel grounds/next door); on-site fitness area | Health/beauty spa listed as nearby; on-site 24-hour fitness facilities |
| Known for | Downtown access, live music at Tap Room, social pool events and Old Florida character | Marina, villa layouts with full kitchens and watersports access (kayaking, motorized watercraft) |
| Parking | Free self-parking (when booked direct); on-site spaces can fill | Self parking available for a surcharge (USD 20 per night) |
| Family-friendly | Welcomes children of all ages; family rooms offered | Not adults-only; welcomes families (adults-only flag: false) |
Hollander sits on Fourth Ave N in the heart of downtown St. Petersburg, close to museums, theaters, and the waterfront.
Choose Hollander if you want to be in the middle of downtown cultural and nightlife options.
Waterline is on Marina Drive in Holmes Beach on Anna Maria Island, focused on marina access and nearby beaches.
Choose Waterline for a Waterfront/Anna Maria Island base rather than downtown city access.
Hollander offers rooms and suites in a restored 1933 Art Deco building with hotel-style layouts.
Hollander is for travelers who want downtown hotel rooms with historic character and easy access to local nightlife.
Waterline's 37 guestrooms are individually furnished villas and two-bedroom layouts with kitchens.
Waterline suits guests who want villa-style space and in-room kitchens for longer stays or family needs.
Hollander has multiple on-site dining options and an active bar program.
Hollander is better if varied on-site dining and an active bar scene matter to you.
Waterline centers dining at a single on-site restaurant and room service (limited hours).
Waterline is fine for relaxed waterfront dining and villa cooking; expect fewer on-site dining choices than a downtown hotel.
Hollander's outdoor heated saltwater pool and terrace are a social hub in downtown St. Petersburg.
Hollander's pool is social and event-focused — pick it for people-watching and local gatherings.
Waterline focuses on marina living: dock, kayak access, and an outdoor pool with terrace and firepit.
Waterline is for guests who prioritize marina access and watersports alongside a quieter pool area.
Hollander combines an adjacent, independently run eco spa with an active downtown nightlife scene.
Hollander suits guests who want spa appointments plus immediate access to nightlife and entertainment.
Waterline offers on-site fitness and a quieter evening environment tied to the marina and beaches.
Waterline is for travelers seeking fitness and low-key waterfront evenings rather than lively nightlife.

Hollander — walkable to museums, theaters, and live-music venues with multiple on-site bars.

Waterline — villa-style rooms with full kitchens and an on-site marina for boating and kayaking.

Hollander — Tap Room, HH20 pool bar and a coffee shop give you more on-site dining options.

Waterline — kitchen-equipped villas and larger two-bedroom layouts make longer stays easier.
Hollander — it’s in downtown St. Petersburg within easy walking distance of many museums and performance venues.
Waterline — it has an on-site marina, dock, kayaking on site, and options for personal motorized watercraft.
Hollander’s pool has an adults-only policy during certain hours/events (some sources note adults-only pool times); Waterline has an outdoor pool but is not listed as adults-only.
Waterline’s villa layouts and kitchens are convenient for families or longer stays; Hollander welcomes families but is more of a traditional downtown hotel.
Explore how Hollander Boutique Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·