
Hollander Boutique Hotel
Best for nightlife, walkable museums/theaters, and a social pool scene.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hollander Boutique Hotel is a 1933 Art Deco boutique hotel in downtown St. Petersburg with a lively pool, on-site bars, and walkable nightlife; read this if you want a centrally located, social downtown base. Anna Maria Beach Resort is a small beachfront resort on Anna Maria Island (Holmes Beach); read this if you want quiet beachfront rooms and easy access to island beaches.
Updated · about 40 km apart (about 25 miles)

Best for nightlife, walkable museums/theaters, and a social pool scene.

Best for quiet beachfront stays and easy access to Anna Maria Island beaches.
When Hollander Boutique Hotel wins: choose Hollander if you want to be in the middle of downtown St. Petersburg — restaurants, live music, museums, and a lively heated saltwater pool with a dedicated pool bar make it the better pick for social, culture-focused travelers.
When Anna Maria Beach Resort wins: choose Anna Maria Beach Resort if your priority is beachfront access, a small property footprint, and a quieter island pace where most activities center on the beach and short island drives.
Bottom line: pick Hollander for downtown energy, on-site dining and nightlife; pick Anna Maria Beach Resort for a classic Gulf beach experience and private beach access.
| Category | Hollander Boutique Hotel | Anna Maria Beach Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic downtown hotel with a social pool, bars, and walkable arts/entertainment | Low-rise, small beachfront resort focused on beach access and relaxed island stays |
| Location | Downtown St. Petersburg, walkable to theaters and museums | Holmes Beach on Anna Maria Island — directly on a private beach (on Gulf Drive) |
| Size (rooms) | About 96 rooms (multiple sources; some listings differ) | 31 rooms |
| Ages / policies | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 25 for the responsible adult | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 25 (property rule) |
| Pools / water | Outdoor heated saltwater pool with free cabanas and poolside HH20 bar; pool parties on some weekends | One outdoor pool and one hot tub + private beach access and beach sun loungers |
| Restaurants & bars | On-site Tap Room Bar & Grill, HH20 poolside bar, Common Grounds coffee shop | Not published |
| Spa & wellness | Harmony Eco Spa adjacent/on grounds (independently owned); on-site fitness centre | Not published |
| Known for | Downtown location, live music, and a lively pool/bar scene | Quiet beachfront lodging on Anna Maria Island with private beach amenities |
| Parking | Free self-parking (can fill; tight spaces) | Free self parking onsite (limited spaces) |
| WiFi | Free WiFi throughout | |
Hollander sits in the heart of downtown St. Petersburg, a short walk to theaters, museums, and waterfront parks.
Choose Hollander if you want immediate access to downtown cultural venues and nightlife.
Anna Maria Beach Resort sits on Gulf Drive in Holmes Beach with direct access to a private beach.
Choose Anna Maria Beach Resort if your priority is being on the sand and close to quiet island beaches.
Hollander offers multiple room types and a mix of standard rooms and suites in a historic building.
Pick Hollander for variety of downtown-facing rooms and historic character.
Anna Maria Beach Resort provides several oceanfront room types and one- and two-bedroom suites with kitchen amenities in some units.
Pick Anna Maria Beach Resort for oceanfront rooms and suite options with small in-room kitchen conveniences.
Hollander has multiple daily dining and drinking options on property and regular live-music nights.
Hollander is the better choice if on-site food, casual dining and evening entertainment matter.
Anna Maria Beach Resort focuses on beach and pool amenities; in-property dining details are not published in the supplier listing.
Choose Anna Maria Beach Resort if you plan to dine off-property or use in-room facilities; the listing does not publish on-site full-service restaurants.
Hollander centers much guest activity around its heated saltwater outdoor pool and pool bar.
If a social pool with a full pool bar and events appeals to you, Hollander is the stronger fit.
Anna Maria Beach Resort combines a single outdoor pool and hot tub with private beach access.
Pick Anna Maria Beach Resort if the priority is sand and sea rather than a hotel-centered pool party scene.
Hollander has an on-site/adjacent independently owned spa plus downtown nightlife within walking distance.
Hollander fits travelers who want spa services plus immediate access to evening entertainment.
Anna Maria Beach Resort emphasizes beach relaxation; the supplier listing does not publish an on-site full-service spa.
Anna Maria Beach Resort suits guests seeking low-key beach time; spa services are not published in the supplier listing.

Hollander — on-site Tap Room and walkable access to downtown venues and bars.

Anna Maria Beach Resort — private beach access, beach loungers and island serenity.

Hollander — full-service Tap Room, pool bar and coffee shop on property.

Anna Maria Beach Resort — a 31-room island resort that feels compact and beach-focused.
Hollander — it's in downtown St. Petersburg within walking distance of theaters, the Museum of Fine Arts and other attractions.
Anna Maria Beach Resort — the supplier listing notes an on-site private beach with loungers and umbrellas.
Both properties welcome guests of all ages; both have a minimum check-in age of 25 for the responsible adult.
Hollander — heated saltwater pool, a dedicated pool bar (HH20) and regular pool events create a more social atmosphere.
Explore how Hollander Boutique Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·