
Hollander Boutique Hotel
Best for downtown culture, easy access to St. Pete attractions, bars, and walkable dining.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hollander Boutique Hotel is a 1933 Art Deco boutique in downtown St. Petersburg for travelers who want museums, restaurants, and nightlife within walking distance. Cedar Cove Resort and Cottages is a small beach resort on Holmes Beach/Anna Maria Island for people prioritizing Gulf-front cottages and a quieter sand-and-sea stay.
Updated

Best for downtown culture, easy access to St. Pete attractions, bars, and walkable dining.

Best for relaxed Gulf-front cottage stays, easy beach access, and small-property privacy.
When Hollander Boutique Hotel wins: Choose Hollander if you want to be in the middle of downtown St. Petersburg — museums, live music, restaurants, and a lively pool bar are a short walk away. It’s the better pick for guests who want nightlife plus a hotel spa and on-site restaurant action.
When Cedar Cove Resort and Cottages wins: Pick Cedar Cove if you prefer a beachside base on Anna Maria Island with individually decorated cottages and suites, direct access to Bradenton/Coquina beaches, and self-parking. It’s the calmer Gulf-front option for families and beach-oriented travelers.
Bottom line: Hollander is an urban boutique for culture and social life; Cedar Cove is a small beach resort for sand, sea views, and cottage-style rooms. Use the downtown-versus-beach lens to choose based on the trip you want.
| Category | Hollander Boutique Hotel | Cedar Cove Resort and Cottages |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Art Deco downtown boutique, active pool/bar scene | Old-Florida beach resort with cottages and suites |
| Location | Downtown St. Petersburg—walking distance to museums, theaters, waterfront | Holmes Beach on Anna Maria Island—steps to Bradenton/Coquina beaches |
| Size (rooms) | About 75–96 rooms (sources vary; often listed as 96-room property) | 19 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 25 for the responsible guest | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools / beach | Outdoor heated saltwater pool with cabanas and HH20 pool bar | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | The Tap Room Bar and Grill (breakfast–dinner), HH20 poolside bar, Common Grounds coffee | Not published |
| Spa & wellness | Harmony Eco Spa on the grounds (independently owned); on-site fitness area | Concierge services and free use of a nearby fitness center; no on-site spa published |
| Known for | Downtown location, live music, historic 1933 building | Beach-front cottages and proximity to Bradenton Beach/Anna Maria Island |
| Parking & transit | Free self-parking when booking direct; downtown shuttles and walkable attractions | Free self-parking on site; preferred airport SRQ (Sarasota-Bradenton Intl.) |
| Family / kid amenities | Family rooms available; children welcome (13+ charged adult rate) | Children's games, beach toys, and family-friendly cottages |
Hollander sits in downtown St. Petersburg within walking distance of theaters, museums, and the waterfront.
Pick Hollander if you want immediate access to downtown St. Pete attractions and an urban evening scene.
Cedar Cove is on Anna Maria Island in Holmes Beach, minutes from Bradenton Beach and Coquina Beach.
Choose Cedar Cove for a Gulf-front, low-key beach location rather than downtown activity.
Hollander offers Art Deco–style rooms and a mix of suites and standard rooms designed for downtown stays.
Rooms are geared to travelers who value location and hotel amenities over large private outdoor spaces.
Cedar Cove provides 19 individually decorated guestrooms including seaside suites and cottages.
Cedar Cove suits guests who want cottage-style or suite accommodations with kitchen conveniences near the beach.
Hollander has several on-site dining options that double as local hangouts.
Hollander is better if you want on-site dining, bar service, and an active social scene every day.
Cedar Cove emphasizes cottage comfort; the supplier listing highlights on-site conveniences but does not list a signature restaurant.
Cedar Cove is suited to guests who prefer to eat in their cottage or explore island restaurants rather than rely on a hotel restaurant.
Hollander centers a social outdoor heated saltwater pool with cabanas and poolside service.
The pool is a key social feature—good for guests who want poolside drinks, music, and events.
Cedar Cove’s listing emphasizes beach access and outdoor grounds rather than an on-site pool.
If sand-and-swim on the Gulf is your priority, Cedar Cove’s beachfront location wins over a hotel pool.
Hollander pairs an on-site/full-service adjacent spa with downtown nightlife and events.
Hollander blends spa and nightlife—best for guests who want both relaxation and evening activity without leaving the hotel area.
Cedar Cove focuses on outdoor activities, family-friendly recreation, and low-key resort services.
Cedar Cove is stronger for outdoor beach activities and cottage-style relaxation than for nightlife or an on-site spa experience.

Hollander for walkable museums, theaters, bars, and live-music nights.

Cedar Cove for direct access to Bradenton and Coquina beaches and cottage-style rooms.

Hollander’s Tap Room, HH20 pool bar and scheduled events keep guests entertained onsite.

Cedar Cove’s kitchen-equipped rooms and varied cottage names suit families and longer beach stays.
Hollander — its downtown location and proximity to theaters, restaurants, and the waterfront make it a convenient base for short city stays.
Cedar Cove — it’s on Holmes Beach with cottage-style rooms, beach toys, and activities nearby that suit family beach days.
Not published — the supplier listing highlights kitchen-equipped rooms and nearby island dining rather than a named on-site restaurant.
Hollander has the adjacent Harmony Eco Spa (independently owned) with published services; Cedar Cove’s listing does not publish an on-site full-service spa.
Explore how Hollander Boutique Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·