
Hollander Boutique Hotel
Best for visitors who want downtown access to museums, live music, on-site restaurants and a full spa nearby.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hollander Boutique Hotel is a downtown St. Petersburg boutique in a 1933 Art Deco building with on-site dining, a heated saltwater pool, and a neighboring full-service spa — read this if you want an arts-and-nightlife base near museums and the waterfront. Serenity By The Sea is a Treasure Island beach-area vacation home with a private balcony and kitchen — read this if you prefer simple Gulf-side lodging and direct beach access near John's Pass.
Updated

Best for visitors who want downtown access to museums, live music, on-site restaurants and a full spa nearby.

Best for travelers who want a simple Gulf beach-area rental with a kitchen and onsite self-parking near Sunset Beach and John's Pass.
When Hollander Boutique Hotel wins: choose Hollander if you want a central downtown base with multiple on-site food & drink venues, a heated saltwater pool with cabanas and an adjacent full-service spa — good for arts, nightlife, and organized hotel programming (pool parties, yoga).
When Serenity By The Sea wins: choose Serenity if you want a Treasure Island beach-area rental close to Sunset Beach and St. Pete/Clearwater beaches, with a private balcony, a kitchen for self-catering and free onsite self-parking.
Bottom line: pick Hollander for an amenity-rich downtown St. Petersburg experience (restaurants, pool, spa, walkable attractions). Pick Serenity By The Sea if you need an affordable Gulf beach-area place on Treasure Island with easy beach access and parking.
| Category | Hollander Boutique Hotel | Serenity By The Sea |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Art Deco boutique, lively downtown atmosphere | Beach-area vacation home, low-key Gulf-side lodging |
| Location | Downtown St. Petersburg; within walking distance of museums, theaters, waterfront | Treasure Island (Sunset Beach) on West Gulf Blvd near St. Pete–Clearwater beaches |
| Size / rooms | Around 75–96 rooms (sources vary); multiple room types including Suite and Standard Room | Not published |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 25 for the responsible guest | All ages welcome (minimum check-in age for property not published) |
| Pools / beach | Outdoor heated saltwater pool with cabanas and HH20 poolside bar | Beach access / beachfront area (Sunset Beach); on-site pool: Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | The Tap Room Bar & Grill (breakfast–dinner), HH20 pool bar, Common Grounds coffee shop | No on-site restaurants listed; self-catering kitchen in the House, Multiple Beds (Serenity By The Sea) |
| Spa & wellness | Harmony Eco Spa (independently owned) next door; on-site fitness center | Not published |
| Parking | Free self-parking on site when booking direct; can fill up | Free self-parking onsite |
| Known for | Downtown location, on-site dining and pool programming (pool parties, yoga) | Close proximity to Sunset Beach and St. Petersburg–Clearwater beaches; short drive to John's Pass |
| Check-in / check-out | Check-in commonly 3:00 PM; check-out most commonly 11:00 AM (some sources show noon) | Check-in begins 4:00 PM; check-out 10:00 AM |
Hollander sits at 421 4th Ave N in the heart of downtown St. Petersburg, a short walk from museums, theaters and the waterfront.
Best for travelers who want to be steps from downtown attractions, dining and evening entertainment.
Serenity By The Sea is on West Gulf Blvd in Treasure Island’s Sunset Beach area, close to the sand and local waterfront attractions.
Best for travelers prioritizing immediate Gulf beach access over downtown walkability.
Hollander offers multiple room types and a Suite option in a restored 1933 Art Deco building.
Choose Hollander for varied room types in a boutique hotel with downtown character.
Serenity By The Sea is offered as a vacation home unit with a kitchen and a private balcony.
Pick Serenity for a simple, self-contained beach rental with a kitchen — good for families or groups who want to self-cater.
Hollander has several on-site food and drink options, from a full restaurant to poolside service and a coffee shop.
Hollander is better if you want consistent on-site dining and bar options without leaving the hotel.
Serenity By The Sea includes a kitchen in the rental; there are no on-site restaurants listed in the supplier facts.
Go with Serenity if you prefer self-catering and being close to beachside restaurants rather than hotel dining.
Hollander highlights an outdoor heated saltwater pool with cabanas and a busy pool schedule.
Hollander is the choice for guests who want a full hotel-pool experience and poolside service.
Serenity By The Sea’s supplier listing emphasizes very close beach access; no pool is published in the supplier facts.
Pick Serenity for immediate beach proximity rather than hotel-style pool amenities.
Hollander offers an on-site fitness center and an independently owned full-service spa adjacent to the hotel.
Hollander is stronger for spa-goers and guests who want downtown nightlife within walking distance.
Serenity By The Sea’s strengths are beach activity access and a quieter neighborhood mood rather than hotel-run wellness or nightlife.
Choose Serenity if you want beach days and local restaurants rather than hotel spa services and downtown nightlife.

Hollander: within easy walking distance of the Museum of Fine Arts, Palladium Theater and other downtown cultural attractions.

Serenity By The Sea: located on West Gulf Blvd in Treasure Island, about 0.1 mi from Sunset Beach and St. Pete–Clearwater beaches.

Hollander: multiple on-site venues—the Tap Room Bar & Grill, HH20 pool bar and Common Grounds coffee shop—cover most meal and drink needs.

Serenity By The Sea: includes a kitchen and private balcony for a self-contained beach rental experience.
Hollander Boutique Hotel is in downtown St. Petersburg within walking distance of major museums, theaters and the waterfront; Serenity By The Sea is on Treasure Island and requires a drive to reach downtown attractions.
No on-site restaurants or bars are listed in the supplier facts; the rental includes a kitchen for self-catering.
The supplier listing does not publish an on-site pool for Serenity By The Sea.
Yes. Hollander welcomes children of all ages (with a 25+ minimum check-in age for the responsible guest). Serenity By The Sea is not listed as adults-only in the supplier facts.
Explore how Hollander Boutique Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·