
Hollander Boutique Hotel
Best for travelers who want downtown attractions, on-site dining/bars, a heated pool and a spa nearby.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Hollander Boutique Hotel is a 1933 Art Deco boutique hotel in downtown St. Petersburg with on-site restaurant, bars, heated saltwater pool and an adjacent full-service spa—good for travelers who want downtown dining, nightlife and a pool scene. Sunshine Lane by Distinctive Beach Rentals is a 3.5-star rental-style vacation home on Treasure Island (a 3‑bedroom house) suited to travelers who prioritize simple beach-area self-catering lodging steps from the sand.
Updated · about 16 km (10 miles) apart

Best for travelers who want downtown attractions, on-site dining/bars, a heated pool and a spa nearby.

Best for travelers who want a private rental-style stay a few steps from Treasure Island beaches and John's Pass.
When Hollander Boutique Hotel wins: Choose Hollander if you want an on-site restaurant and multiple bars, regular pool events and a full-service spa nearby plus easy walkability to St. Petersburg theaters, museums and nightlife.
When Sunshine Lane by Distinctive Beach Rentals wins: Choose Sunshine Lane if your priority is a standalone 3‑bedroom vacation home right at Treasure Island beaches and Johns Pass with self-catering space and snorkeling/water activities on the doorstep.
Bottom line: Hollander is the better pick for an amenity-rich downtown stay with dining, bars, and programmed pool life; Sunshine Lane is the straightforward beach rental for travelers who want private space steps from the Gulf.
| Category | Hollander Boutique Hotel | Sunshine Lane by Distinctive Beach Rentals |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Art Deco boutique in downtown St. Petersburg; social public spaces and regular events | Vacation-home, rental-style lodging in a beach neighborhood |
| Location | Downtown St. Petersburg, walkable to museums, theaters and waterfront | Treasure Island / Sunshine Beach, steps from St. Petersburg - Clearwater Beaches and close to John's Pass |
| Size (rooms) | About 75–96 rooms (sources vary; hotel lists multiple room types) | Not published |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; minimum check‑in age 25 for the booking adult | All ages welcome; minimum check-in age 25 enforced at check-in at this property |
| Pools / beach | Outdoor heated saltwater pool with cabanas, HH2O poolside bar and regular pool events | Beachfront access / steps to the sand; no hotel pool listed (beach and on-site snorkeling) |
| Restaurants & bars | On-site Tap Room Bar & Grill, HH2O pool bar and Common Grounds coffee shop | Self-catering rental home — no published on-site restaurants or bars |
| Spa & wellness | Harmony Eco Spa adjacent/next door (full-service, independent) and on-site fitness center | Not published |
| Known for | Downtown location, live music at the Tap Room, pool parties and an Art Deco building | Immediate beach access and proximity to John's Pass Village & Boardwalk |
| Parking | Free self-parking when booking direct; spaces can fill up | Limited onsite parking |
| Accessibility | Elevator and public-area accessibility noted; property is non-smoking | Wheelchair accessible – no (upper floors by stairs only) |
Hollander sits in the heart of downtown St. Petersburg within walking distance of theaters, museums and the waterfront.
Pick Hollander to be in the middle of downtown culture, dining and nightlife.
Sunshine Lane is on Treasure Island a few steps from St. Petersburg–Clearwater Beaches and a short walk to John's Pass.
Pick Sunshine Lane for immediate beach access and proximity to John's Pass attractions.
Hollander offers multiple room types and suites combining Old Florida character with modern essentials.
Hollander is for travelers who want hotel services, multiple room types and on-site public areas.
Sunshine Lane is offered as an individually decorated vacation home — a 3‑bedroom house.
Sunshine Lane suits visitors who prefer the space and privacy of a beach house.
Hollander includes several on-site dining and drinking options.
Hollander is the clear choice if you want on-site meals, bars and scheduled events.
Sunshine Lane is a vacation home intended for self-catering; no on-site restaurant is published.
Sunshine Lane fits travelers who prefer a rental kitchen and nearby local restaurants.
Hollander's signature amenity is its outdoor heated saltwater pool and active poolside program.
Choose Hollander for a hotel pool scene with amenities and scheduled activities.
Sunshine Lane's prime amenity is direct, immediate access to the beach and water activities.
Pick Sunshine Lane for beach-and-water activity access rather than hotel pool facilities.
Hollander combines an adjacent full-service spa with downtown nightlife within walking distance.
Hollander is the better pick if you want spa services plus nightlife on foot.
Sunshine Lane focuses on beach recreation rather than an on-site spa or nightlife program.
Sunshine Lane fits guests prioritizing beach activities and casual nearby dining rather than hotel wellness facilities.

Hollander — on-site restaurant and bars, a staffed front desk, heated saltwater pool with events, and an adjacent full-service spa.

Sunshine Lane — steps from the sand and close to John's Pass Village for water activities and beach time.

Sunshine Lane — a 3‑bedroom house layout provides private space for families or small groups.

Hollander — walkable to museums, theaters, concert venues and downtown dining.
Hollander — it has the Tap Room Bar & Grill, HH2O pool bar and Common Grounds coffee shop on-site.
Sunshine Lane — the listing places the home steps (0.1 km) from St. Petersburg–Clearwater Beaches on Treasure Island.
Both enforce a minimum check-in age of 25 for the responsible adult booking the property.
Hollander offers free self-parking (can fill up); Sunshine Lane lists limited onsite parking.
Explore how Hollander Boutique Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·